Made Guys » Book and Film Reviews » Why Boardwalk Empire Tops the List of Gangster TV Series

Why Boardwalk Empire Tops the List of Gangster TV Series

Dominic Grimaldi

The Undisputed King of Gangster Shows - Boardwalk Empire

Boardwalk Empire doesn’t just offer a plot; it presents a labyrinthine series of events that keep viewers on the edge of their seats. The show’s writers employ a level of detail that goes beyond mere storytelling, creating a web of interconnected subplots that add depth to the main narrative. For instance, the political machinations of Nucky Thompson aren’t just a side note; they serve as a lens through which viewers can understand the complexities of governance and corruption during the Prohibition era. This attention to detail extends to the show’s minor characters as well, who are often given their own arcs, contributing to the series’ overall complexity.

Moreover, the show’s character development is nothing short of revolutionary. Characters are not static; they evolve, regress, and sometimes surprise us, just like real people. Take Margaret Schroeder, played by Kelly Macdonald, as an example. She starts as a marginalized housewife but undergoes a transformation that is both believable and compelling, eventually becoming a key player in Nucky’s business ventures. This level of character development is rarely seen in television, making Boardwalk Empire a standout in a sea of superficial shows.

Additionally, the series masterfully incorporates real historical events, like the Black Sox Scandal and the Women’s Suffrage movement, into its narrative. These events are not just window dressing; they serve to contextualize the actions and decisions of the characters, adding another layer of depth to the story. This fusion of history and fiction not only educates the viewer but also enriches the storytelling, making each episode a multi-dimensional experience.

The Genius Behind the Camera

The brilliance of Boardwalk Empire can be traced back to its creators and producers, who bring a unique set of skills and experiences to the table. Terence Winter, the show’s creator, cut his teeth on The Sopranos, a series known for its complex characters and intricate plotlines. Winter brings this expertise to Boardwalk Empire, ensuring that the show meets the highest standards of storytelling. His ability to create multi-dimensional characters and weave complex narratives sets him apart as one of the most skilled showrunners in the industry.

Martin Scorsese’s involvement in the series is another feather in its cap. Known for films like “Goodfellas” and “The Departed,” Scorsese brings a cinematic quality to Boardwalk Empire that is rarely seen in television. His influence is evident not just in the pilot episode, which he directed, but also in the overall visual style of the series. The show’s cinematography, influenced by Scorsese’s eye for detail, elevates it from a mere TV show to a visual masterpiece. His role as an executive producer also ensures that the series maintains its high production values, making it a cut above the rest.

Furthermore, the collaboration between Winter and Scorsese creates a synergy that is palpable in every frame of the series. Winter’s storytelling prowess combined with Scorsese’s visual genius creates a product that is greater than the sum of its parts. This collaborative spirit extends to the rest of the crew, from the set designers to the costume department, each contributing their expertise to create a show that is both visually stunning and narratively compelling.

A Visual Feast

Boardwalk Empire doesn’t merely recreate the 1920s; it brings the era back to life with a level of visual artistry that goes beyond mere set design. The show employs a team of experts, from historians to artisans, who work tirelessly to ensure that every visual element is historically accurate. This commitment to authenticity extends to the smallest details, such as the period-appropriate tableware in Nucky’s suite or the historically accurate signage on the boardwalk. These details may seem minor, but they contribute to the show’s overall sense of immersion, making it easier for viewers to lose themselves in the world of 1920s Atlantic City.

Boardwalk Empire tv show - Atlantic City

The series employs innovative cinematography techniques to enhance its storytelling. The use of color palettes, for instance, is carefully curated to reflect the mood of specific scenes or characters. Dark, muted tones might be used to emphasize the grim reality of criminal life, while brighter, more vibrant colors could signify moments of triumph or emotional intensity. This level of visual storytelling is rarely seen in television and serves to elevate Boardwalk Empire into the realm of cinematic art.

The Soundtrack – A Period-Appropriate Masterpiece

The role of music in Boardwalk Empire extends far beyond mere entertainment; it serves as a narrative tool that adds depth and context to the series. The show employs a team of musicologists and historians who meticulously curate the soundtrack to ensure that it aligns with the events and themes of each episode. For example, the use of period-specific instruments, such as the cornet or the banjo, adds an extra layer of authenticity to the series. These instruments not only reflect the musical trends of the time but also serve to highlight the cultural shifts that were taking place during the Prohibition era.

The series often uses music to foreshadow events or reveal character traits. A jaunty tune might play as a character concocts a cunning plan, while a somber melody could accompany a moment of loss or betrayal. This use of music as a narrative device adds a layer of complexity to the series, making it a more engaging and emotionally resonant experience for the viewer.

The Cast – A Roster of Talent

The performances in Boardwalk Empire go beyond mere acting; they offer a masterclass in character interpretation. Steve Buscemi’s portrayal of Nucky Thompson is a study in complexity, capturing the nuances of a man torn between his desire for power and his sense of moral responsibility. Buscemi brings a level of vulnerability to the character that adds depth to his more ruthless actions, making him a more relatable and compelling figure.

Boardwalk Empire - Nucky Thompson  and Joseph P. Kennedy

The supporting cast also brings a level of expertise that is rarely seen in television. Michael Shannon, who plays the morally conflicted Agent Nelson Van Alden, offers a performance that is both intense and nuanced. His character serves as a foil to Nucky, offering a different perspective on the moral ambiguities of the Prohibition era. Similarly, Kelly Macdonald’s portrayal of Margaret Schroeder provides a glimpse into the challenges faced by women during this period, from the limitations imposed by society to the opportunities created by the underground economy.

The chemistry between the cast members adds an extra layer of realism to the series. The relationships between characters feel genuine, thanks in part to the palpable rapport between the actors. This chemistry is not the result of chance; it’s the product of rigorous casting processes and extensive rehearsals, which ensure that each actor is perfectly suited to their role.

The Cultural Impact

Boardwalk Empire’s influence permeates far beyond the confines of your typical TV screen. The show has become a cultural touchstone, sparking conversations about issues that were relevant in the 1920s and continue to resonate today. Topics like corruption, the role of government, and the ethics of criminality are dissected and discussed in forums, classrooms, and even scholarly articles. The series has inspired a new wave of interest in the Prohibition era, leading to an uptick in academic courses and publications focused on this transformative period in American history.

The show has had a tangible impact on the tourism industry, particularly in locations where it was filmed or set. Atlantic City, for instance, has seen a surge in visitors keen to walk the same boardwalk as Nucky Thompson, or at least the modern version of it. This has led to a variety of Boardwalk Empire-themed tours and events, further cementing the show’s status as a cultural phenomenon.

The Awards and Critical Acclaim

While awards are not the sole measure of a show’s quality, they do offer an external validation that can’t be ignored. Boardwalk Empire’s impressive haul of 20 Primetime Emmy Awards is not just a nod to its entertainment value but also an acknowledgment of its technical prowess and narrative depth. The series has also received nominations for Golden Globes and Screen Actors Guild Awards, categories that often serve as bellwethers for long-term success and cultural impact.

But beyond the trophies and accolades, the series has garnered high praise from critics for its nuanced approach to storytelling. Renowned publications have lauded its ability to weave complex narratives without sacrificing historical accuracy, a feat that requires a delicate balance of research, creativity, and technical skill. This critical acclaim has further solidified the show’s reputation, attracting a more discerning audience who appreciate the finer points of filmmaking and storytelling.

The Lasting Appeal

In an age where viewers are inundated with a plethora of viewing options, the enduring popularity of Boardwalk Empire speaks volumes about its quality. The show’s narrative complexity and character depth offer a timeless appeal that transcends generational divides. It’s not just a show you watch; it’s a show you study, discuss, and ponder long after the credits roll. This intellectual engagement is a key factor in its lasting appeal, setting it apart from other shows that may entertain but ultimately leave no lasting impression.

The advent of streaming platforms has breathed new life into the series, introducing it to a younger audience who may have missed its original run. This new generation of viewers has found a wealth of material to dissect, from the show’s thematic depth to its historical nuances. Social media platforms are rife with discussions and fan theories about Boardwalk Empire, proving that its relevance has not waned over the years.

The Real-Life Connections: Gangsters and History Intersect

Al Capone – More Than a Name

Boardwalk Empire - Al Capone

One of the most compelling aspects of Boardwalk Empire is its incorporation of real-life gangsters into its fictional world. Take Al Capone, for instance. Portrayed by Stephen Graham, Capone isn’t merely a side character but a fully realized individual. The show delves into his rise to power in Chicago, capturing the brutality and cunning that marked his criminal career. Boardwalk Empire doesn’t just use Capone as a plot device; it examines the man behind the myth, offering viewers a glimpse into his personal life, including his relationship with his deaf son. This nuanced portrayal adds a layer of authenticity to the series, making it more than just a fictional narrative.

Arnold Rothstein – The Brain Behind the Operations

Boardwalk Empire - Arnold Rothstein

Another historical figure who makes an appearance is Arnold Rothstein, played by Michael Stuhlbarg. Known as the man who fixed the 1919 World Series, Rothstein was a criminal mastermind involved in various illegal enterprises, from gambling to bootlegging. His character serves as a mentor to Nucky Thompson, guiding him through the treacherous waters of organized crime. Rothstein’s inclusion in the series serves a dual purpose: it adds historical depth and provides a counterpoint to Nucky, highlighting the latter’s evolution as a criminal entrepreneur.

The Atlantic City Conference

Boardwalk Empire also pays homage to significant events in gangster history, such as the Atlantic City Conference. This was a real-life meeting that took place in 1929, where major crime figures gathered to discuss the future of their illegal operations. In the series, this event serves as a pivotal moment, bringing together key characters and setting the stage for future conflicts. By integrating this historical event, the show adds another layer of realism, allowing viewers to appreciate the complexities of criminal enterprises during the Prohibition era.

The Volstead Act

Boardwalk Empire - Prohibition

The series kicks off with the enactment of the Volstead Act, the law that ushered in Prohibition and, by extension, the era of bootlegging. By starting at this point, Boardwalk Empire immediately grounds itself in the socio-political climate of the 1920s. The show examines how this law didn’t merely ban alcohol but catalyzed an underground economy and gave rise to criminal empires. The Volstead Act serves as more than a backdrop; it’s a catalyst for the events that unfold, shaping the lives of every character on the show.

Lucky Luciano and Meyer Lansky

Boardwalk Empire - Meyer Lansky and Lucky Luciano

Younger gangsters like Lucky Luciano and Meyer Lansky also find their way into the series, representing the next generation of organized crime. Their ambitions and actions within the show mirror their historical ascent, as they eventually become significant figures in the American underworld. Their inclusion serves to show the changing dynamics of organized crime, as the old guard begins to give way to a new, more ruthless set of leaders.

Why Boardwalk Empire Stands Alone

In a genre saturated with clichés and predictable plotlines, Boardwalk Empire offers a refreshing change. It combines historical accuracy with compelling storytelling, brought to life by a talented cast and crew. Its visual and auditory elements serve to enhance, rather than distract from, the intricate plot and complex characters. The series has set a new standard for what a gangster-themed show can and should be, making it the best choice for viewers seeking a series that offers both substance and style.

In sum, Boardwalk Empire is more than a television show; it’s a masterclass in storytelling, character development, and production design. It offers a multi-layered viewing experience that satisfies on both an intellectual and emotional level, making it the best gangster series to date.

About the author

Leave a Comment