Made Guys » Mafia Legends » A Closer Look at Joseph Colombo’s Life and Influence

A Closer Look at Joseph Colombo’s Life and Influence

Dominic Grimaldi

Joseph Colombo's Shifting Roles in Crime and Society

Joseph Colombo’s birth in Brooklyn in 1923 set the stage for a life that would be anything but ordinary. Growing up in an Italian-American household, the cultural values and traditions of his heritage played a significant role in shaping his worldview. While his initial criminal activities were minor, they served as a stepping stone to more significant endeavors. His involvement with the Profaci crime family, one of the notorious Five Families of New York, was a pivotal moment in his life.

The Profaci family, led by Joe Profaci, was deeply entrenched in various criminal enterprises, including loan sharking, racketeering, and illegal gambling. Colombo’s skills in these illicit activities didn’t go unnoticed. He quickly climbed the ranks, gaining the trust and confidence of the family’s leadership. However, it was his audacious act of warning Gaetano “Tommy” Lucchese and Carlo Gambino about a planned hit against them that set him apart. This act was not just a betrayal of his then-boss, Joe Magliocco; it was a calculated risk that could have cost him his life.

By warning Lucchese and Gambino, Colombo did more than just save their lives; he shifted the tectonic plates of Mafia politics in New York City. This act led to a reevaluation of alliances and loyalties among the Five Families. It also put Colombo in the good graces of powerful figures who would later support his ascension to leadership. His audacity and cunning not only disrupted the existing order but also paved the way for his future as a Mafia boss.

The Colombo Crime Family and the Commission

Joseph Colombo’s defiance against Joe Magliocco was a watershed moment in the annals of organized crime. Magliocco’s demotion was a public humiliation, a rarity in a world where disputes were often settled in more lethal ways. Colombo’s promotion, on the other hand, was a testament to his strategic acumen and his ability to navigate the treacherous waters of Mafia politics. He took the reins of what would become the Colombo crime family, named in his honor, and began to shape it according to his vision.

The Colombo family became an influential member of the Commission, the governing body of the American Mafia. This organization was not just a loose coalition of crime families; it was a complex, hierarchical structure with its own set of rules and regulations. Colombo’s family was deeply involved in various criminal enterprises, from loan sharking and extortion to illegal gambling and racketeering. Under his leadership, the family expanded its operations, diversifying into legitimate businesses as a cover for its illegal activities.

However, Colombo’s rapid rise to power raised eyebrows among the old guard of the Mafia. Questions about his suitability and qualifications for leadership were whispered in the dark corners of social clubs and meeting places. His public persona, especially his vocal stance against what he perceived as defamation of Italian-Americans, was a point of contention. In a world where anonymity was often the key to survival, Colombo’s high-profile activities were seen as reckless by some.

Yet, despite the skepticism and veiled criticisms, Colombo’s position within the Mafia hierarchy remained secure. His ability to maintain the loyalty of his subordinates, coupled with his knack for forming strategic alliances, ensured that he remained a force to be reckoned with. His leadership style was a blend of traditional Mafia values and modern business acumen, a combination that made him one of the most compelling figures in the history of organized crime.

In both these phases of his life, Joseph Colombo demonstrated a keen understanding of power dynamics and an uncanny ability to turn situations to his advantage. Whether it was his early days in the criminal underworld or his time as the head of a major crime family, Colombo’s actions were always calculated, his strategies well-thought-out. His life serves as a fascinating case study in the exercise of power, the complexities of leadership, and the blurred lines between right and wrong in the world of organized crime.

The Italian-American Civil Rights League

The formation of the Italian-American Civil Rights League (IACRL) by Joseph Colombo in the early 1970s was a strategic masterstroke that served multiple purposes. On the surface, it was a social movement aimed at fighting the stigmatization of Italian-Americans, often unfairly associated with organized crime. However, the IACRL also functioned as a shield for Colombo, providing him with a veneer of legitimacy and a platform to challenge law enforcement agencies openly.

The IACRL didn’t just make noise; it took concrete actions that had far-reaching implications. Accusing the FBI of bias and conspiracy against Italian-Americans was a bold move that resonated with a community that had long felt marginalized. The organization’s success in influencing the Justice Department was a significant victory, not just for the IACRL but also for advocacy groups challenging institutional bias. It wasn’t merely a win against stereotyping; it was a challenge to the state’s power to define social narratives.

The rapid growth of the IACRL was another testament to Colombo’s organizational skills. Attracting 40,000 dues-paying members within a year is no small feat for any organization, let alone one that was so controversial. The benefit concert by Frank Sinatra, a towering figure in American entertainment, added a layer of glamour and respectability to the IACRL, making it more palatable to mainstream America. Sinatra’s involvement wasn’t just a celebrity endorsement; it was a cultural validation of the IACRL’s objectives.

Public Persona and Media Attention

Joseph Colombo’s knack for manipulating public perception was both his strength and his Achilles’ heel. In an era without social media, Colombo understood the power of traditional media in shaping public opinion. His consistent denial of involvement in organized crime wasn’t just a legal strategy; it was a public relations campaign aimed at redefining his identity. By portraying himself as a real estate entrepreneur, he was tapping into the American dream, the idea that anyone could rise above their circumstances through hard work and ingenuity.

However, Colombo’s media savvy had its drawbacks. His high-profile appearances and interviews were a deviation from the Mafia’s traditional code of omertà, the vow of silence that had long been a cornerstone of organized crime. While his visibility made him a household name, it also painted a target on his back. Law enforcement agencies, already skeptical of his activities, found in his public persona further reason to intensify their scrutiny. His media appearances weren’t just a PR strategy; they were a high-stakes gamble that risked exposing his criminal enterprises.

Colombo’s media visibility created tension within the Mafia community. His outspoken nature and willingness to court public attention were seen as reckless by more traditional Mafia figures, who valued discretion and operated in the shadows. His actions were not just a challenge to law enforcement agencies; they were a challenge to the established norms of organized crime.

In both his advocacy work through the IACRL and his manipulation of media, Joseph Colombo displayed a complex understanding of power dynamics in a changing American society. He leveraged social movements, celebrity culture, and media attention to build a multifaceted identity that defied easy categorization. Yet, these same strategies that brought him fame and influence also attracted controversy and danger, making him one of the most enigmatic figures in the annals of American organized crime and social activism.

The Fateful Day: June 28, 1971

The events of June 28, 1971, were not just a personal tragedy for Joseph Colombo; they were a seismic shock that reverberated through multiple spheres of American life. The public rally at New York’s Columbus Circle, organized by the Italian-American Civil Rights League (IACRL), was supposed to be a crowning moment for Colombo. It was meant to solidify his role as a civil rights leader and further legitimize the IACRL. Instead, it became the setting for an act of violence that would change the course of his life and have far-reaching implications.

Jerome A. Johnson, the man who shot Colombo, was a relatively unknown figure, and his motives remain shrouded in mystery. His subsequent killing in the chaos that followed the shooting has only deepened the enigma. Theories about who might have orchestrated the attack range from rival Mafia families seeking to eliminate a too-visible adversary, to government agencies uncomfortable with Colombo’s rising influence and ability to challenge their narratives. The lack of conclusive evidence has led to a proliferation of conspiracy theories, each more intricate than the last, involving various actors from the underworld and the corridors of power.

The shooting didn’t just incapacitate Colombo; it also cast a long shadow over the IACRL, raising questions about its legitimacy and future. The violent act, carried out in such a public manner, also had a chilling effect on other advocacy groups and social movements, forcing them to reconsider the risks involved in challenging powerful institutions. In essence, the events of that day served as a cautionary tale about the volatility and unpredictability of activism in a society fraught with complex power dynamics.

The Final Years and Legacy

Joseph Colombo’s final years were a stark contrast to the life he had led. Confined to his Brooklyn home in a near-comatose state, he was a shadow of the man who had once been a vibrant and controversial figure. His death in 1978 due to heart failure, a direct result of his injuries, seemed to close the chapter on a life that had been anything but ordinary. However, in many ways, his legacy was just beginning to take shape.

Colombo’s death had a profound impact on the Colombo crime family, signaling the end of an era characterized by his unique blend of criminal enterprise and public activism. His absence created a power vacuum, leading to internal strife and challenges from rival families. The family’s operations underwent significant changes, reflecting a shift in leadership style and priorities. However, the imprint of Colombo’s audacious strategies and public relations savvy remained, influencing subsequent leaders and shaping the family’s identity in the years to come.

Beyond the world of organized crime, Colombo’s life continues to be a subject of academic inquiry, journalistic investigation, and public fascination. His dual roles as a Mafia boss and a civil rights advocate challenge conventional wisdom about the nature of power, activism, and criminality. His life raises uncomfortable questions about the American justice system, media ethics, and the social constructs that define heroes and villains.

Joseph Colombo’s legacy is a complex tapestry of contradictions, woven from threads of ambition, audacity, cunning, and tragedy. He remains an enigmatic figure whose life serves as a lens through which to examine the complexities of American society in the latter half of the 20th century. Whether viewed as a criminal mastermind, a flawed hero, or a symbol of the challenges and paradoxes that define the American experience, Joseph Colombo’s life and legacy offer a rich field for exploration and interpretation.

About the author

Leave a Comment